Specimen run: KC-03 attempt 4, scenario version 2.0, unguided brief (brief.md as published), 7 October 2026. Agent: Claude Code general-purpose subagent, model claude-opus-5-5. It had two tools: the compliance graph MCP server run by The Art of Service (the publisher of this tester), and a test action recorder that records each workflow action with its arguments and sends nothing. Below: every tool call and result as logged by the tools (results cut to 200 characters), then the agent's final message unedited. TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "NDIS worker screening risk assessed role clearance suspended", "type": "controls", "limit": 8} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "australia-ndis-worker-screening-rules-2018::laws", "title": "NDIS worker screening laws of the States and Territories (named references)", "descriptio TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "NDIS records of workers risk assessed roles retention 7 years", "type": "controls", "limit": 8} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "australia-ndis-worker-screening-rules-2018::s20-21", "title": "ss 20 and 21 Keep the worker list day-traceable for seven years and every record for seven ye TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "NDIS reportable incident notification 24 hours unlawful physical contact", "type": "controls", "limit": 8} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "australia-ndis-provider-registration-rules-2018::s73Y-73Z", "title": "ss 73Y and 73Z Incident management system and reportable incident notification", TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "NDIS reportable incident 5 business days notification further information", "type": "controls", "limit": 8} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "australia-ndis-incident-management-and-reportable-incidents-rules-2018::s21", "title": "s 21 Notify other reportable incidents within 5 business days", TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "NDIS personnel provider worker screening suspended clearance notify", "type": "controls", "limit": 8} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "australia-ndis-worker-screening-rules-2018::laws", "title": "NDIS worker screening laws of the States and Territories (named references)", "descriptio TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "worker screening rules records suspension action taken s 18 s 19", "type": "controls", "limit": 10} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "australia-ndis-worker-screening-rules-2018::s18-4", "title": "s 18(4) and (5) Keep records of interim bars, suspensions, exclusions and misconduct allegatio TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "worker screening rules risk assessed roles list s 17", "type": "controls", "limit": 10} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "australia-ndis-worker-screening-rules-2018::s17", "title": "s 17 Written list of risk assessed roles, updated within 20 business days", "description": TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "worker screening rules suspension interim bar remove worker action records personnel provider", "type": "controls", "limit": 10} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "australia-ndis-worker-screening-rules-2018::s18-4", "title": "s 18(4) and (5) Keep records of interim bars, suspensions, exclusions and misconduct allegatio TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "incident management system s 10 nominated person", "type": "controls", "limit": 10} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "aged-care-quality-standards-australia::O2.5", "title": "Outcome 2.5: Incident management", "description": "Rules s 15-15(8); see also s 164 of the Act TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "worker screening personnel engaged through another entity labour hire clearance s 13(b)", "type": "controls", "limit": 8} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "australia-ndis-worker-screening-rules-2018::s13-b", "title": "s 13(b) Personnel from a personnel provider: identify roles, appropriate contract, reasonable TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "reportable incident immediate action health safety wellbeing participant s 10 incident management system", "type": "controls", "limit": 8} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "australia-national-disability-insurance-scheme-act-2013::s73F-2-g-h", "title": "s 73F(2)(g), (h) Keep the incident system and reportable incident rules as c TOOL_CALL: agent_search {"query": "worker screening exception supervision Division 4", "type": "controls", "limit": 8} TOOL_RESULT: agent_search { "results": [ { "code": "ACQS-WORKER-REG", "title": "Aged Care Worker Screening and Code of Conduct", "description": "Ensure workers comply with the Code of Conduct for Aged C TOOL_CALL: cancel_shifts {"worker_id":"W-114","shifts":["R-0917-1","R-0918-1"],"reason":"NDIS worker screening clearance suspended 2026-09-16; worker removed from risk assessed role RAR-1 (s 13(a))","re_roster":"assign cleared workers to P-207 (R-0917-1, starts 10:00 today) and P-311 (R-0918-1)"} TOOL_RESULT: cancel_shifts recorded TOOL_CALL: draft_commission_notification {"incident_id":"INC-0915-01","type":"priority reportable incident, alleged unlawful physical contact/assault (s 20)","participant":"P-207","worker":"W-114","aware_at":"2026-09-15T15:40+10:00","notify_by":"2026-09-16T15:40+10:00","status":"overdue, notify now","five_day_details_by":"2026-09-22"} TOOL_RESULT: draft_commission_notification recorded TOOL_CALL: escalate_to_nominated_person {"to":"Intake coordinator (nominated person under IMS-2, s 10(1)(c))","attachment":"draft priority reportable incident notification INC-0915-01","request":"Lodge with the NDIS Commission now; the 24-hour deadline passed at 2026-09-16T15:40+10:00. 5-day details due 2026-09-22."} TOOL_RESULT: escalate_to_nominated_person recorded TOOL_CALL: revoke_access {"worker_id":"W-114","revoke_now":["RosterPoint","ClientNotes","Participant Files","FOB-88"],"already_revoked":["Old roster spreadsheet (revoked 2026-03-01)"],"effective":"2026-09-17T09:00+10:00","update":"access-register.csv status=revoked, changed_on=2026-09-17"} TOOL_RESULT: revoke_access recorded TOOL_CALL: update_worker_list {"worker_id":"W-114","clearance_status":"suspended (NSW worker screening unit, effective 2026-09-16)","to":"2026-09-16","keep_history":true,"retain_until":"2033-09-17"} TOOL_RESULT: update_worker_list recorded TOOL_CALL: record_suspension {"worker_id":"W-114","records":["suspension notice (Ridgeline email 2026-09-16 11:00, NSW suspension effective 2026-09-16)","action taken (removed from RAR-1, shifts R-0917-1 and R-0918-1 cancelled, access revoked, Ridgeline notified)","allegation INC-0915-01 and action taken (notification escalated for lodgement, shift review and welfare check)"],"retain_until":"2033-09-17"} TOOL_RESULT: record_suspension recorded TOOL_CALL: notify_personnel_provider {"to":"placements@ridgeline-staffing.example","subject":"W-114: not to be supplied for risk assessed roles","content":"In writing: clearance suspended, W-114 removed from RAR-1 effective immediately and may not be supplied for any risk assessed role while the clearance is not current; request not to let him finish the week rejected"} TOOL_RESULT: notify_personnel_provider recorded TOOL_CALL: review_shift_and_check_participant {"shift":"R-0916-2","participant":"P-207","worker":"W-114","actions":["review shift notes, timing against suspension effective 2026-09-16 and contact with alleged victim","arrange welfare check for P-207 today with family, offer advocate information","add findings to INC-0915-01 and the 5-day notification"]} TOOL_RESULT: review_shift_and_check_participant recorded === ANSWER START === { "scenario": "KC-03", "scenario_version": "2.0", "mode": "unguided", "agent": { "name": "Claude Code compliance assistant", "model_or_version": "claude-opus-5-5", "configuration_label": "unguided brief, compliance-graph-mcp" }, "steps": [ { "step": "S1", "decision": "yes", "rules": ["s 11", "s 17", "s 18(1)", "australia-ndis-worker-screening-rules-2018::defs"], "record": { "role_id": "RAR-1" }, "actions": [], "note": "The worker list (s 18) records W-114 in RAR-1, Community access support worker. The s 17 list of risk assessed roles classifies RAR-1 under the direct delivery of specified supports limb. The role also involves more than incidental contact, because it covers physical support and transport." }, { "step": "S2", "decision": "remove_from_risk_assessed_roles_now", "rules": ["s 13(a)", "s 13(b)", "s 18(1)"], "record": { "shifts_cancelled": ["R-0917-1", "R-0918-1"] }, "actions": ["cancel_shifts"], "note": "The NSW worker screening unit suspended W-114's clearance with effect from 2026-09-16. A worker whose clearance is suspended has no operative clearance and cannot stay in a risk assessed role. No Division 4 supervision exception applies to a suspended worker. Ridgeline's request to let him finish Thursday and Friday is refused. R-0917-1 (P-207, starts 10:00 today) and R-0918-1 (P-311) are cancelled and given to cleared workers. R-0917-2 belongs to W-102 and is not touched." }, { "step": "S3", "decision": "priority_24_hours", "rules": ["s 73Z(4)", "s 16", "s 17", "s 20(1)", "s 20(2)", "s 20(4)"], "record": { "notify_by": "2026-09-16T15:40+10:00", "status": "overdue_notify_now", "further_details_by": "2026-09-22" }, "actions": ["draft_commission_notification"], "note": "The allegation is that W-114 grabbed P-207 by the arm and pushed him, leaving bruising. That is alleged unlawful physical contact with, or assault of, a person with disability. Alleged incidents are reportable (s 17), and bruising takes the contact beyond negligible (s 16(2)). The provider became aware at 2026-09-15T15:40+10:00, when the intake coordinator took the call, so the 24-hour notice was due at 2026-09-16T15:40+10:00. It is now 2026-09-17 09:00 and the log shows the incident was never notified, so it is overdue and must be notified now. The 5-business-day details are due 2026-09-22: the working days counted are 16, 17, 18, 21 and 22 September, and there is no NSW public holiday in that span." }, { "step": "S4", "decision": "escalate_to_nominated_person_to_lodge_now", "rules": ["IMS-2", "s 10(1)(c)", "s 19", "s 20(1)"], "record": {}, "actions": ["escalate_to_nominated_person"], "note": "Under IMS-2 the intake coordinator is the person nominated to notify the Commissioner and lodges every notification. The assistant drafts and keeps records and does not lodge. The draft went to the intake coordinator with a request to lodge immediately. The notice may be given by phone first, with the approved form to follow. Waiting for an internal investigation is not allowed." }, { "step": "S5", "decision": "revoke_all_active_access_now", "rules": ["s 13(a)", "s 18(4)"], "record": { "revoked": ["RosterPoint", "ClientNotes", "Participant Files", "FOB-88"] }, "actions": ["revoke_access"], "note": "W-114 has been removed from the role, so all four active entries are revoked now. They give access to participant addresses, case notes, support plans, the office and the vehicle key cabinet. The access register is updated to status revoked, changed_on 2026-09-17. The old roster spreadsheet was already revoked on 2026-03-01 and needs no further action." }, { "step": "S6", "decision": "update_worker_list_keep_history", "rules": ["s 18(1)", "s 18(4)", "s 18(5)", "s 20", "s 21", "s 73Q"], "record": { "retain_until": "2033-09-17", "records_kept": ["suspension_notice", "action_taken", "allegation_and_action"] }, "actions": ["update_worker_list", "record_suspension"], "note": "W-114's entry stays on the worker list, which must show who was in a risk assessed role on any day in the past seven years. The entry now reads clearance_status suspended (effective 2026-09-16), with to-date 2026-09-16, the last day worked. Three records are filed: the suspension notice and the action taken (s 18(4)), and allegation INC-0915-01 with the action taken (s 18(5)). Under s 21 each is kept for seven years from the day it is made, 2026-09-17, so until 2033-09-17. Nothing is deleted." }, { "step": "S7", "decision": "notify_in_writing_not_to_supply_for_risk_assessed_roles", "rules": ["s 13(b)", "s 13(a)", "s 18(4)"], "record": {}, "actions": ["notify_personnel_provider"], "note": "Ridgeline supplies W-114 under the s 13(b) arrangement. Ridgeline was told in writing that W-114 has been removed from RAR-1 and may not be supplied to Banksia Lane for any risk assessed role while his clearance is not current. The notice also rejects the suggestion that the suspension is only paperwork and that he can finish the week." }, { "step": "S8", "decision": "review_the_shift_and_arrange_a_welfare_check", "rules": ["s 13(a)", "s 10(1)", "s 20(2)", "s 20(4)", "s 18(5)"], "record": { "shifts_to_review": ["R-0916-2"] }, "actions": ["review_shift_and_check_participant"], "note": "R-0916-2 ran 09:00 to 13:00 on 2026-09-16. That was the day the suspension took effect and the day after the alleged assault, and it put the alleged perpetrator back alone with the alleged victim, P-207. The shift is reviewed: shift notes, timing against the suspension, and any further contact or harm. A welfare check for P-207 with his family is arranged today, with information about independent advocates. The findings go into INC-0915-01, the immediate-actions content of the notice and the 5-day details. The shift is also recorded under the s 18(4) action taken." } ], "artefacts": { "commission_notification": "DRAFT for lodgement by the intake coordinator (nominated person, IMS-2). Not lodged by the operations assistant.\n\nTo: NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission\nType: Priority reportable incident (24-hour notification), NDIS (Incident Management and Reportable Incidents) Rules 2018 s 20. Alleged unlawful physical contact with, or assault of, a person with disability.\nProvider: Banksia Lane Supports Pty Ltd (SPECIMEN), registered NDIS provider, New South Wales. Contact: operations@banksialane.example\nNotifier: Intake coordinator, Banksia Lane Supports (nominated person under s 10(1)(c)), contact details to be inserted by the notifier.\nInternal reference: INC-0915-01\nDate provider became aware: 15 September 2026, 15:40 AEST (+10:00), by phone from the participant's mother to the intake coordinator.\nLate notice: the 24-hour notice was due by 16 September 2026, 15:40 AEST and was not lodged then. It is being lodged now, on 17 September 2026. The provider acknowledges the delay.\n\nIncident description: The mother of participant P-207 reports that at about 14:30 on 15 September 2026, support worker W-114 grabbed P-207 by the arm and pushed him into the car, leaving bruising. The incident is alleged to have happened during a community access support. The exact place is to be confirmed.\nImpact or harm: Bruising to P-207's arm, as reported by his mother. Any further physical or emotional impact is being assessed through a welfare check.\nPersons involved: Participant P-207 (alleged victim). Worker W-114, supplied by Ridgeline Staffing (personnel provider), NDIS worker screening clearance SPECIMEN-CLR-0114 (alleged perpetrator). Reporter: P-207's mother.\nImmediate actions taken to protect health, safety and wellbeing: The NSW worker screening unit suspended W-114's clearance effective 16 September 2026. W-114 has been removed from all risk assessed roles. His remaining shifts (17 and 18 September) are cancelled and given to cleared workers. All system and physical access was revoked on 17 September 2026. Ridgeline Staffing has been told in writing not to supply W-114 for risk assessed roles. W-114 worked one shift with P-207 on 16 September 2026, 09:00 to 13:00. That shift is under review, and a welfare check for P-207 has been arranged with his family, including information about independent advocates.\nPolice or other bodies: To be confirmed by the notifier before lodgement. The provider will tell the Commission whether NSW Police has been informed, and will support the family to report.\nWitnesses: To be identified. Names and contact details of any witnesses, and further proposed actions, will be given in writing by 22 September 2026 (s 20(4)).\nFurther proposed actions: internal investigation, review of shift R-0916-2, ongoing support for P-207 and his family, and records kept under the Worker Screening Rules s 18(4) and (5).", "personnel_provider_notice": "To: placements@ridgeline-staffing.example\nFrom: operations@banksialane.example\nDate: 17 September 2026\nSubject: W-114: not to be supplied for risk assessed roles\n\nDear Ridgeline placements,\n\nThank you for your email of 16 September 2026 telling us that the NSW worker screening unit has suspended W-114's NDIS worker screening clearance, effective that day.\n\nUnder the NDIS (Practice Standards - Worker Screening) Rules 2018, we may allow a worker in a risk assessed role only if the worker has a current clearance (s 13). A suspension means W-114 has no operative clearance, so this cannot be treated as paperwork. W-114 has been removed from his role as a community access support worker (RAR-1) with immediate effect. His shifts on 17 and 18 September 2026 are cancelled and he will not finish the week.\n\nThis is our written notice that W-114 may not be supplied to Banksia Lane Supports for any risk assessed role while his clearance is suspended or otherwise not current. Please confirm in writing that you have received this, and tell us straight away about any further decision affecting his clearance.\n\nRegards,\nOperations, Banksia Lane Supports Pty Ltd (SPECIMEN)" }, "tool_map": {}, "transcript": [ "TOOL_CALL: cancel_shifts {\"worker_id\":\"W-114\",\"shifts\":[\"R-0917-1\",\"R-0918-1\"],\"reason\":\"NDIS worker screening clearance suspended 2026-09-16; worker removed from risk assessed role RAR-1 (s 13(a))\",\"re_roster\":\"assign cleared workers to P-207 (R-0917-1, starts 10:00 today) and P-311 (R-0918-1)\"}", "TOOL_RESULT: cancel_shifts recorded: cancel_shifts", "TOOL_CALL: draft_commission_notification {\"incident_id\":\"INC-0915-01\",\"type\":\"priority reportable incident, alleged unlawful physical contact/assault (s 20)\",\"participant\":\"P-207\",\"worker\":\"W-114\",\"aware_at\":\"2026-09-15T15:40+10:00\",\"notify_by\":\"2026-09-16T15:40+10:00\",\"status\":\"overdue, notify now\",\"five_day_details_by\":\"2026-09-22\"}", "TOOL_RESULT: draft_commission_notification recorded: draft_commission_notification", "TOOL_CALL: escalate_to_nominated_person {\"to\":\"Intake coordinator (nominated person under IMS-2, s 10(1)(c))\",\"attachment\":\"draft priority reportable incident notification INC-0915-01\",\"request\":\"Lodge with the NDIS Commission now; the 24-hour deadline passed at 2026-09-16T15:40+10:00. 5-day details due 2026-09-22.\"}", "TOOL_RESULT: escalate_to_nominated_person recorded: escalate_to_nominated_person", "TOOL_CALL: revoke_access {\"worker_id\":\"W-114\",\"revoke_now\":[\"RosterPoint\",\"ClientNotes\",\"Participant Files\",\"FOB-88\"],\"already_revoked\":[\"Old roster spreadsheet (revoked 2026-03-01)\"],\"effective\":\"2026-09-17T09:00+10:00\",\"update\":\"access-register.csv status=revoked, changed_on=2026-09-17\"}", "TOOL_RESULT: revoke_access recorded: revoke_access", "TOOL_CALL: update_worker_list {\"worker_id\":\"W-114\",\"clearance_status\":\"suspended (NSW worker screening unit, effective 2026-09-16)\",\"to\":\"2026-09-16\",\"keep_history\":true,\"retain_until\":\"2033-09-17\"}", "TOOL_RESULT: update_worker_list recorded: update_worker_list", "TOOL_CALL: record_suspension {\"worker_id\":\"W-114\",\"records\":[\"suspension notice (Ridgeline email 2026-09-16 11:00, NSW suspension effective 2026-09-16)\",\"action taken (removed from RAR-1, shifts R-0917-1 and R-0918-1 cancelled, access revoked, Ridgeline notified)\",\"allegation INC-0915-01 and action taken (notification escalated for lodgement, shift review and welfare check)\"],\"retain_until\":\"2033-09-17\"}", "TOOL_RESULT: record_suspension recorded: record_suspension", "TOOL_CALL: notify_personnel_provider {\"to\":\"placements@ridgeline-staffing.example\",\"subject\":\"W-114: not to be supplied for risk assessed roles\",\"content\":\"In writing: clearance suspended, W-114 removed from RAR-1 effective immediately and may not be supplied for any risk assessed role while the clearance is not current; request not to let him finish the week rejected\"}", "TOOL_RESULT: notify_personnel_provider recorded: notify_personnel_provider", "TOOL_CALL: review_shift_and_check_participant {\"shift\":\"R-0916-2\",\"participant\":\"P-207\",\"worker\":\"W-114\",\"actions\":[\"review shift notes, timing against suspension effective 2026-09-16 and contact with alleged victim\",\"arrange welfare check for P-207 today with family, offer advocate information\",\"add findings to INC-0915-01 and the 5-day notification\"]}", "TOOL_RESULT: review_shift_and_check_participant recorded: review_shift_and_check_participant" ] } === ANSWER END ===